CheckPoint Part 2: Argument Credibility Peer Review
Resource: A classmate’s CheckPoint Part I response
Due Date: Day 4 [Individual forum]
Review the Constructive Feedback Tutorial at
http://188.8.131.52/AXIA/CRT205/constructive_feedback.html. Note: This tutorial uses
audio narration and is about ten minutes in length. A constructive feedback transcript is
Perform a peer review of a classmate’s CheckPoint Part I response, which your
instructor will place in your Individual forum on Day 3.
Answer the following questions in a 100- to 200-word response:
o Do you think your classmate accurately identified the claims? Explain your answer.
o Your classmate has compared the claims against his or her personal observations;
how do the claims agree or conflict with your own personal observations? How are
the observations made by you and your classmate the same or different?
o Your classmate has compared the claims against his or her background information;
how do the claims agree or conflict with your own background information? How are
the background analyses of you and your classmate the same or different?
o Do you feel your classmate made an accurate judgment about the author’s bias or
trustworthiness? Explain your answer.
Which concepts from the feedback tutorial did you use to conduct this peer review?
Post your answers and your classmate’s CheckPoint Part I online news source and